Entitled Students and Capitalism

My friend Alex says this about the following article:

I love the embedded assumptions here: that education is and ought to be job training; that life as a wage slave is what young people ought to aspire to; that deadlines are important simply because authority has the right to discipline and punish; that our education system is failing because students aren’t obeying like they should; that students are ‘coddled’ and ‘entitled’ because they aren’t interested in school as a model of industrial discipline and a place to be sorted and valued according to the fucked-up values of capitalism. I’m not saying there aren’t profound problems with our model of education today but these are not them, nor is this bullshit task force of ‘stake holders’ the solution.


NSCC instructor frustrated with ‘entitled’ students

High school students are being “coddled” on assignment deadlines, according to one instructor at Nova Scotia Community College.

Steffie Hawrylak-Young has taught communications at NSCC for almost 30 years. In the last decade, she says, there has been a shift in how her students adjust to college learning — and it’s not good.

A provincial government survey indicates she is not alone in her frustration.

“A lot of our young students are very entitled,” Hawrylak-Young told CBC News. “They have probably been used to getting a badge for every single little thing that they do, and they’re very disappointed when they’re being critiqued.

“In many of our businesses and industries, performance evaluation is very real, and they seem to have a hard time accepting that their performance is not there yet.”

Flexible deadlines

Hawrylak-Young suggests high school teachers are allowing students to hand in assignments weeks or even months late. When students expect the same treatment in her class, she says, they are surprised.

“The late assignments just become bundled up and they never ever have a chance to get the feedback they need to improve for the next assignment. Further to that, it’s a little disappointing when they don’t care to improve,” said Hawrylak-Young.

“Maybe they’ve been coddled. Maybe they’ve been allowed to make mistakes without consequences.”

The Department of Education agrees there is need for improvement.

The task force was created following a Department of Education survey that received 4,000 comments from teachers and parents, many outlining the issues around deadlines and attendance.

Sandra McKenzie, deputy minister of education and early childhood development, is co-chairing a transition task force. It was created in response to complaints of students not being prepared for the workforce or post-secondary education.

Provincewide policy needed

“The objective of the transition task force is to look at key transition points and how can we make sure that they’re transitioning successfully,” said McKenzie.

Sandra McKenzie

Sandra McKenzie, deputy minister of education and early childhood development, says there’s a mix of guidelines across school boards. (CBC)

School superintendents, principals, business owners and post-secondary representatives are taking part in the discussions.

McKenzie recognizes there needs to be provincewide policy, rather than a “mishmash” of guidelines.

“In the past, the department created guidelines, and then each board would create its own policy and then each school would interpret the policy at the school level. What has resulted is that different practices across the province by schools.”

The panel is expected to make recommendations to cabinet ministers by the end of March.

About flexosaurus

I am an anthropologist and Associate Professor who loves to play guitar and comment on social injustice in whatever form it may take
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s